Black coffee cuts risk of death, but sugar eliminates benefits

Your morning coffee habits may prolong your life, but only if you skip sugar and cream.

A comprehensive study tracked more than 46,000 American adults for more than a decade and found that drinking 1-3 cups of black coffee a day reduced the risk of death for all causes by 17%.

However, adding sweeteners and saturated fat completely eliminates these protections, which shows how you prepare coffee is as important as drinking coffee. The findings challenge common practices for coffee doctors that can offset the addition of its natural health benefits.

The study, published in the Journal of Nutrition, is one of the most detailed exams for coffee health effects to date. Compared to previous studies, which simply asked people whether to add cream or sugar, this survey accurately measures the consumption of each additive.

Best place for coffee benefits

“Coffee is one of the most expensive drinks in the world, with nearly half of American adults drinking at least one cup a day, and it’s important to know what this means for health,” said Fang Fang Zhang, senior author and professor at the Friedman School of Nutrition at Tufts University. “Study consumption between 1-3 cups a day prevents the strongest protection for premature death.

Mortality benefits peaked at a peak of 2-3 cups per day, with participants having a 17% lower risk of death compared to non-coffee users. Interestingly, spending more than three cups a day does not provide additional benefits, and cardiovascular protection is actually weakened at higher levels of consumption.

This dosage response relationship suggests that coffee consumption range is the optimal range. Too little won’t make the most of the benefits, and too much may reduce them.

Key findings:

• 1-2 cups per day: Reduce all-cause mortality by 16%
• 2-3 cups per day: all-cause mortality rate decreases by 17%
• Black coffee: Reduce mortality by 14%
• High sugar/fat coffee: No mortality observed
• Cardiovascular Benefits: Moderate intake reduces up to 35%

Additive problems

Where coffee preparations are sharply diverging, there will be health effects based on addition. Black coffee and the additives with the smallest content of coffee (defined as less than 2.5 grams of added sugar and 1 grams of saturated fat per cup) both have significant mortality benefits.

But coffee filled with sugar and cream has no protection. This discovery is of great significance to millions of Americans, who usually add a lot of sweeteners and dairy to their daily brews.

“The health benefits of coffee may be attributed to its bioactive compounds, but our results suggest that adding sugars and saturated fats may reduce mortality benefits,” Zhang explained.

Drinkers see different effects

A key finding not found in the initial report involves the interaction between coffee and tea consumption. The mortality benefits of coffee are completely limited to those who drink tea from time to time. Among drinkers, coffee consumption was not significantly associated with reduced risk of death.

This unexpected finding suggests that consuming tea may interfere with the protection mechanism of coffee. The researchers hypothesized that tea could alter the bioavailability of coffee’s beneficial compounds or compete with coffee in shared biological pathways to neutralize the protective effect of coffee.

This interaction has never been reported in previous coffee studies and can explain some inconsistent findings in the scientific literature. It also shows that people should consider their overall beverage consumption, not just isolated beverages.

Caffeine-driven benefits

The study shows that almost all mortality rates come from caffeine-containing coffee. Decaffeinated coffee has no significant association with reduced risk of death, suggesting that caffeine itself plays a crucial role in the protective effect of coffee.

This finding supports theories about the beneficial mechanisms of caffeine. Stimuli affect energy balance by increasing metabolic rates and have anti-inflammatory properties that can prevent weight gain and insulin resistance. Previous studies have linked caffeine consumption directly to reducing mortality risk.

However, the coffee benefits of lack of caffeine may also reflect the relatively low consumption of DECAF by Americans, only 0.17 cups per day in those who drink.

Cardiovascular protection stands out

Although coffee consumption does not significantly affect cancer mortality, cardiovascular benefits are particularly striking. Compared to non-coffee people, those who drink 2-3 cups a day have a 33% lower risk of dying from heart disease or stroke.

But this cardiovascular protection has an important warning: It is only suitable for coffees with low or no added saturated fat. Despite containing the same beneficial coffee compounds, coffee preparations are higher than saturated fats (from cream or whole milk can usually provide cardiovascular benefits).

This specificity suggests that saturated fat addition may directly offset the cardiovascular protection mechanism of coffee, possibly by promoting inflammation or affecting cholesterol metabolism.

Measuring important things

“Seldom studies have studied how coffee additives affect the link between coffee consumption and mortality risk, and our study is the first to quantify how much sweet and saturated fat is added,” said Bingjie Zhou, a recent PhD. Graduated from Tufts University.

The researchers defined the “low” addition as less than 5% of the daily value — about a teaspoon of sugar or five tablespoons equivalent to five tablespoons, 2% of milk per cup. These thresholds are consistent with federal dietary guidelines, which recommend adding sugar and saturated fat content.

Most previous studies simply asked people if they added anything to their coffee, missing the key difference between milk splash and big sweet coffee drinks.

The meaning of the real world

What does this mean for your daily coffee routine? Research shows that black coffee provides the greatest health benefits, but small amounts of milk or sugar do not completely eliminate the protection.

But popular coffee shop drinks rich in syrup, whipped cream and seasonings may negate any health benefits. Typical flavored lattes or frappuccinos contain more sugar and saturated fat than the “lower” thresholds studied.

These findings also raise questions about artificial sweeteners, which the study has not been specifically studied. Future research will need to determine whether sugar substitutes can retain the benefits of coffee while satisfying those who prefer sweet drinks.

Biological mechanisms

The health benefits of coffee may be derived from its abundant bioactive compounds other than caffeine. Chronic acid is the main phenolic ingredient in coffee beans that improves insulin sensitivity and lowers blood pressure studied in animals and humans.

Coffee polyphenols may also positively affect the diversity of the gut microbiota, potentially promoting overall health by improving digestive function and immune response. These mechanisms can explain the widespread protective effect of coffee on multiple causes of death.

However, added sugars and saturated fats may interfere with these beneficial pathways, which may be counteracting coffee’s natural protective compounds through inflammatory responses or metabolic disruption.

expect

An estimated 150 million American adults drink coffee every day, and these findings provide peace of mind and guidance. The consumption of coffee does seem to be protective against premature death, but preparation methods significantly affect these benefits.

The study supports current dietary guidelines, suggesting limited consumption of added sugar and saturated fat. This also suggests that public health news about coffee should emphasize preparation methods, not just consumption.

Future research will require examining specific types of coffee additives (natural vs. artificial sweeteners, different dairy products and plant-based alternatives) to provide coffee enthusiasts with more detailed guidance to seek the greatest health benefits from their daily brewing.

Related